Types advantages and disadvantages of antennas in wireless communication

written by: Brian Rodrigues; article published: year 2006, month 08;



In: Categories » Electronics and communication » Wireless and mobile computing » Types advantages and disadvantages of antennas in wireless communication

Almost everyone uses at least one antenna each day. In fact, the majority of people use antennas for many conveniences in their daily life, whether they realize it or not. Devices such as keyless entry systems, freeway toll passes, satellite TV systems, pagers, cell phones, and wireless networks all require antennas. Very few people who use these antennas can explain how and why they work. Let's take a brief look at antenna technology, and how antennas relate to our radio frequency networks.

Antennas are merely an extension of a radio transmitter or receiver. As a signal is generated, it is passed from the radio to the antenna to be sent out over the air and received by another antenna, then passed to another radio. The signal that is generated and later transmitted is measured in Hertz (Hz); not the car rental company, but rather a measurement unit of cycles per second. This is better defined as the amount of time it takes a radio wave to complete a full cycle. Imagine that you have a Slinky (a coiled metal spring) on a smooth surface with one end attached to the floor. If you start to move the other end from side to side, you will begin to create waves. These waves represent the radio frequency (RF) energy being sent out over the air. By moving your hand side to side at a slow pace, thus creating longer waves, you are creating a low frequency. If you speed up the movement from side to side, making the waves shorter but more frequent, you are generating a higher frequency. Lower frequencies generally have the ability to travel farther distances, but are more subject to high latency that limits data flow. A higher frequency has a lower (better) latency, but it is limited in distance and penetration of objects such as buildings and other obstructions.

For example, consider your local FM radio station. If they broadcast their signal on frequency 103.5MHz, this translates to 103,500,000 cycles per second. Their signal can be heard all over your city, even inside buildings and houses, with very little interruption. Meanwhile, an AM radio station two states away is broadcasting on 1320KHz, which translates to 1,320,000 cycles per second. With the correct antenna placed outside, you can receive their signal from a longer distance, but with the added difficulty of needing to adjust your antenna.

As you can see, antennas are fundamental components to the transmission of radio frequencies. In many situations, a lower power signal transmitted using a good antenna can arrive at its destination with more accuracy than a high-powered signal transmitted using a poor antenna. Antennas are rated by the amount of gain that they provide. Gain is the increase in power you get by using a directional antenna.

If an antenna's gain is just specified as dB, check with the manufacturer to see whether the rating is dBi or dBd. If they cannot tell you, or simply do not know, save your money and go someplace else.

A dipole antenna has 2.14dB gain over a 0-dBi isotropic antenna. So if an antenna gain is given in dBd and not dBi, add 2.15 to it to get the dBi value.

As stated above, most antennas are sold with gain measured in dBi, but this is not the only factor to consider when evaluating overall performance. For example, the power input to the antenna plays a major part. Most 802.11b wireless cards transmit 32mW of power. Looking at the conversion chart in, you can see that 32mW (the Pwr column stands or "Power") is equal to 15dBm. The dBm is calculated by the following:

dBm = 10 log (32mW/1)
dBm to Power Conversion Chart

dBm

Pwr

dBm

Pwr

53

200W

25

320mW

50

100W

24

250mW

49

80W

23

200mW

48

64W

22

160mW

47

50W

21

125mW

46

40W

20

100mW

45

32W

19

80mW

44

25W

18

64mW

43

20W

17

50mW

42

16W

16

40mW

41

12.5W

15

32mW

40

10W

14

25mW

39

8W

13

20mW

38

6.4W

12

16mW

37

5W

11

12.5mW

36

4.0W

10

10mW

35

3.2W

9

8mW

34

2.5W

8

6.4mW

33

2W

7

5mW

32

1.6W

6

4mW

31

1.25W

5

3.2mW

30

1.0W

4

2.5mW

29

800mW

3

2.0mW

28

640mW

2

1.6mW

27

500mW

1

1.25mW

26

400mW

0

1.0mW

For instance, if you know that a typical card is transmitting 15dBm and you want to use, say, a 3-dBi antenna, you can use the following equation to calculate the Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP):

15dBm + 3dBi = 18dBm (64mW) EIRP

The Federal Communication Commission (FCC) currently limits mobile 802.11 stations to 1W or 30dBm EIRP. Fixed stations are given a slight exception to the rule, and are allowed to exceed the 1W limitation. When calculating for fixed stations, they are required to subtract 1dB for every 3dB over 6dBi of antenna gain. The following example demonstrates this for a Linksys WAP11 and a 24-dBi antenna:

20dBm + 24dBi = 44dBm or 25W (44dbM – ((24dBi – 6dB)/3)) = EIRP (44dBm – (18dBi / 3)) = EIRP (44dBm – 6dBi) = EIRP EIRP – 38dBm or 6.4W

In addition to antenna gain and transmitter power, you should also consider the difference in sizes of antennas. Depending on the frequency and type of antenna, there will be a variety of sizes to choose from. The size of the antenna is directly related to the frequency for which it is used. For example, consider a CB radio installed in a car that operates between 26.965MHz (channel 1) and 27.405MHz (channel 40). If you want to have a full wavelength antenna for channel 1, it would need to be 36.491 feet long. This is calculated as follows:

L(in feet) = 984/f(in MHz) L = 984/26.965MHz L = 36.491 feet

Now compare that CB antenna to a full wavelength antenna used by a police officer to communicate with his dispatcher on 460.175MHz.

L(in feet) = 984/f(in MHz) L = 984 / 460.175 MHz L = 2.142 feet

As you can see, there is a difference of about 34.349 feet between the two antennas. Fortunately for us, wireless 802.11b networks operate in the 2.4GHz or 2400MHz range, thus making the antennas very small.

There are two primary types of antennas that are used on wireless networks— omni-directional and directional. Omni-directional antennas can receive and transmit from all sides (360 degrees). These are useful when covering a large room, or for providing general coverage. Contrary to popular belief, a true omni-directional antenna is not capable of having any gain. Most antennas sold as omni-directional do not send the radio frequency in all directions. The design of the antenna will null the signal on the Y-axis, and concentrate the power across the X-axis.

Directional antennas take the RF energy and concentrate it in a specific direction. This can be compared to a naked light bulb versus a flashlight. The light bulb would be similar to the omni-directional antenna, as it gives off light in all directions equally. In contrast, the flashlight (similar to the directional antenna) focuses the light bulb with the help of a reflector, and concentrates it in a single direction. Directional antennas are helpful when you are creating point-to-point wireless links, or when you are trying to reduce the RF signal "bleed" in a specific location.

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. Wireless Attacks ~ War Driving
When a surveillance attack is either impossible or too difficult, war driving is an effective alternative. In many situations, war driving follows and adds information to a prior surveillance attack. Conversely, the information obtained from random war driving often leads to a surveillance attack on a discovered location. The term war driving is borrowed from the 1980s phone hacking tactic known as war dialing. War dialing involves dialing all the phone numbers in a given sequence to search for modems. In fact, this method of ...

2. How To Get Photo Quality Prints
There are a variety of ways to get photo-quality prints from your digital images. You can make them yourself with a printer at home, or have a photo finisher do the work for you. Many camera stores offer photo finishing from digital images. Simply take in your memory card, order the prints, and pick them up the next day. This service is now available in most drugstore chains, too—instead of dropping off a roll of film while running your errands, you leave them your memory card instead. You can also order prints throu...

3. Wireless Privacy Protocols ~ WEP detailed
The Wired Equivalent Privacy protocol is incorporated as part of the IEEE 802.11b protocol. Actually, the standard only calls for 40-bit WEP, but almost all vendors offer up to 128-bit WEP. To secure data, WEP uses the RC4 algorithm to encrypt the packets of information as they are sent out from the access point or wireless network card. This is the same algorithm used in many other Internet applications that require security, such as Secure Sockets Layer (SSL). SSL is the most common protocol used by online stores to e...

4. Wireless Attacks ~ Rogue Access Points
Rogue access points are those connected to a network without planning or permission from the network administrator. For example, we know one administrator in Dallas who just did his first wireless security scan (war driving) on his eight-building office campus. To his surprise, he found over thirty access points. Worse, only four of them had authorization to be connected to the network. Needless to say, heads rolled. Rogue access points are becoming a major headache in the security industry. With the price of low-end ac...

5. Wireless Network Protocols ~ Advantages and Disadvantages of Bluetooth
There are various wireless communication protocols. These technologies range in scope from long distance WLANs to one-meter IrDA devices. Each of these technologies has its niche, as well as its attendant strengths and weaknesses. For example, WLANs enable the transmission of data up to several hundred feet, but often require manual configuration changes that are difficult to implement. On the other hand, IrDA permits a seamless connection between devices without the need for extra configuration. However, their usability is de...

6. Wireless Network Protocols ~ Understanding HomeRF and IrDA
About the same time WECA approved the 802.11 standard, several other types of wireless technologies were being introduced. Although a few have made a rather impressive niche in the Personal Area Network (PAN) market, the only other WLAN technology that came close to competing with 802.11 was HomeRF. Using the Shared Wireless Access Protocol (SWAP), HomeRF merges the 802.11 FHSS standard with the six voice channels based on Digital Enhanced Cordless Telecommunications (DECT). In other words, the home network included both ...

7. WLAN Broadcasting ~ MiniStumbler ~ a wireless network scanner
MiniStumbler is a very user-friendly wireless network scanner that listens for beacon signals coming from open and broadcasting WLANs. In addition, this program will provide a plethora of information that makes it very useful for both hackers and the security professionals. As you will see, MiniStumbler might be small, but it packs a load of power in its functionality. Installing MiniStumbler MiniStumbler is a basic one-file program that simply needs to be downloaded, unzipped, and placed in the My Documents sha...

8. How To Present a Digital Slideshow
Slideshows are an age-old photographic tradition. Digital cameras make it easier than ever to present your images to many people at once. Most digicams have a "video out" capability that lets you connect your camera directly to a television for playback on a large screen. If your camera has this functionality, it most likely has a slideshow mode that allows you to choose images that are stored on the memory card and present them on the television in timed intervals. All you have to do is turn on the stereo for some ba...

9. Concerns for Mobile Enterprises
Although it is one thing for organizations to keep up with the latest industry trends, making it happen in everyday life is a totally different story. The following are some of the key concerns of enterprises that are contemplating a mobile e-commerce strategy: Security: Wireless networks are very easy to break into and difficult to monitor. Your enterprise assets must be protected. Management: Effective management of the components that make up a mobile enterprise, all the way from servers to the ...

10. Wireless Attacks ~ Client to Client Hacking
Clients exist on both wireless and wired networks. A client can range from anything such as a Network Attached Storage (NAS) device, to a printer, or even a server. In a typical ad-hoc network, there are no servers or printers—just other individuals' computers. Because the majority of consumer operating systems are Microsoft based, and since the majority of users do not know to how to secure their computers, there is plenty of room to play here. For example, an attacker can strike at a laptop that uses a wireless ...