Thomas White`s Life Hangs in the Balance of Legal Arguments

written by: Donna Gallegos; article published: year 2007, month 06;


In: Categories » Arts and entertainment » People and humanities » Thomas White`s Life Hangs in the Balance of Legal Arguments

Thomas White, age 13 when accused of entering Joplin Memorial Middle School armed with a weapon on Oct. 9, 2006, will wait until July 6 to learn whether his defense team has successfully argued that his constitutional rights were violated when he was certified as an adult in December 2006. Although the rifle discharged into the ceiling, no one was injured. If convicted of all charges, he could potentially be sentenced to life in prison.

Thomas’ defense team, public defenders Brett Meeker, James Egan and Kathleen Miller, asked that Thomas be remanded back to the juvenile court, sighting a number of infringements on his U.S. Constitutional and Missouri Constitutional rights associated with his certification as an adult.
 
Egan argued before Circuit Court Judge David Mouton, that Thomas’ certification as an adult violates his constitutional rights as a juvenile for his “protection against Cruel and Unusual Punishment.” Further, he argued that Thomas’ original legal council, Charles Lonardo, “fell below that of a competent attorney” sighting Leonardo’s failure to object to testimony in the certification hearing that was inadmissible. Lonardo also failed to introduce available evidence that could have demonstrated to the court that the juvenile system has adequate remedies for treatment and rehabilitation of Thomas.
 
Although Judge Mouton had cleared his afternoon calendar, he disallowed testimony by defense experts in attendance. Instead, Mouton directed Egan to sum-up what the experts would have testified to. Egan sighted important information that should have been heard by the court. The experts would have testified about Thomas’ competency, the certification evaluation and the learning disability that was unknown until after his arrest.
  
Had the court allowed Professor Donna Bishop’s testimony, who specializes in juvenile justice and juvenile delinquency, the court would have heard about two large-scale studies that indicate juveniles who receive harsher penalties when tried as adults are not “scared straight.” In fact, after their release, they tend to re-offend sooner and more often than those treated in the juvenile system.
  
The lone witness allowed to testify was Vincent Hillyer, executive director of the Boys & Girls Town of Missouri, a treatment facility with an impressive success rate, that helps youths to deal with the social issues that have manifested themselves into behavior deemed inappropriate in society. Hillyer testified that he interviewed Thomas and has accepted him into the treatment program available at the facility. Hillyer said that if deemed necessary to properly and fully rehabilitate Thomas, the young man could remain in the Boys & Girls Town facility until he is 21.
  
Hillyer’s impression of Thomas was that he is a young man who was pushed to the edge of coping with social issues and that Thomas simply made a very big mistake in dealing with the social challenges he faced.

“Boys & Girls Town is not a summer-camp program,” Hillyer told the court. “We’re not there to punish these kids; we’re there to help them deal with the issues that have brought them there.” He also noted that he lives on the grounds with his two young children and would not have accepted Thomas into the program if he felt he was putting himself, his own children or the other residents at risk.
 
“I just don’t understand,” Norma White, Thomas’ mother said after the hearing. “It’s all just such a waste of time and tax payers money, and my son is not getting the help he needs in adult jail. There’s no education; no treatment being offered. He’s just sitting there waiting for these legal wheels to turn at a snail’s pace, knowing full-well, even when it’s over and the trial is finished, it will just have to start all over again. I mean, how much time and money will be wasted before my son gets the help he needs.”
 
April Harper and her 14-year-old son, Aaron – who attended Memorial Middle School with Thomas, and in fact, suffered the same bullying that Thomas suffered there – also attended Friday’s hearing. Harper said, in watching Thomas sit stoically in the courtroom, as the prosecutors sat across the table from him, snickering and rolling their eyes at the defense’s arguments, she does not understand how anyone could look at Thomas as an adult. “What is the matter with these people,” she asked. “How can they not see that he’s a child, not an adult? He is a child who desperately needs a hug from his mother.”
 
Harper withdrew her son, Aaron, from school and is now home-schooling him. She said, given the similarities in Thomas’ and Aaron’s situations - the relentless bullying they both suffered and both their repeated requests not to be sent back to school, she realized it could be her son that now sits in prison attire, shackled in a court of law, with his life hanging in the balance. “It was difficult for Aaron to see his friend escorted in by sheriff’s deputies, in shackles,” Harper said of her son. “He’s heartbroken for Thomas. He wanted so much to go sit with him and to let him know that he’s not alone; that he’s not forgotten. He’s just heartbroken for his friend, and we don’t understand how anyone could see Thomas as an adult – let alone an entire legal system. I just cannot believe there is nothing we can do stop this.”
 
Donna Gallegos, administrator of Justice for Juveniles, a nationwide group that advocates against children being tried as adults – expressed grave concern for Thomas after the hearing. “Thomas needs guidance, intervention and treatment, not to be treated as one of the worst of the worst offenders that serves a life sentence in adult prison,” she said. “Public safety can be protected in juvenile court where Thomas would be in the Division of Youth Services until age 18, or at Boys and Girls Town until age 21.”

Justice for Juveniles is keeping a close eye on the Thomas White case and is hopeful the American legal system will not continue to victimize him.  “America is out of touch with the rest of the world, for we are treating our children in ways that are shameful, degrading, inhumane and immoral,” Gallegos said. “A child on Monday cannot be an adult on Tuesday.”

For more information, to find out how you can help support the child advocacy efforts of Justice for Juveniles and Thomas White, email Justiceforjuveniles@yahoo.com or contact Kathy Harris at 850-994-9688.

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. How to determine if a piece is worth restoring
The easiest way to determine if a piece is worth restoring is to decide if it has sentimental value. If so, then the best way to make it last for generations (or centuries) is with regular and proper maintenance. Whether silver plated or Sterling, the easiest way to protect your piece is through regular and gentle polishing. At Lawrence Miller & Co. we recommend using Tarni-Shield (by 3M) polishing cream. Hagerty also makes a good polishing cloth (silver duster), but Tarni-Shield is a less abrasive polish, it leaves a protective f...

2. Gel Candles are Great for the Imagination at Home
The imagination is quite a mystical, magical and creative energy that enlivens the spirits of any who use it. Forming a mental image of a desired location, activity or feeling brings about a peace within that's comforting. How does the world of gel candles relate to this phenomenon? I'm glad that you asked! Gel candles can stir the creative power of the mind to travel towards all sorts of heavenly thoughts. The themes of these creations range from powdery soft beaches, coral reefs and underwater fantasies to the simple, carefree...

3. Passion for my Nation ~ Nepal
Mother, I sense your soul. These few words express empathy towards a nation where dreams do begin but surprisingly never seem to cease where love flows like rivulets from the Himalayas and reach out hearts, where endurance has survived pain, and hands filled with love have pushed the nation on a track of peace and harmony. Peace and harmony that have emerged out of struggle, reflecting that peace that is seen in the silent and forbearing eyes of the god man named Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha whose holy feet touched the dust of this ...

4. Literally Scared Out of Our Wits
Are some medical and academic authorities irrationally sabotaging progress? Change is scary. Little-understood new ideas can be especially frightening. When we’re scared, we become irritable, or sarcastic - even hostile.  And we no longer have our wits about us. Even small changes are scary, such as learning a new computer program. Big changes, such as seeing our worldview begin to crumble, drive us nuts. When that happens, we can no longer think straight. Rational thinking has been blocked. We are "lit...

5. The Man on the Moon
Please forgive the general “flip” tones of this attempt at a jazz song piece about Batman. Yes, that was one of the secret identities of the Black Man that was the below fascinating but sometimes dryly obtuse person. They were all sanctioned back in the 1960s by the one true author of the incredible life contained within this frighteningly brief but not tepid article. In short, while driving this petty insignificant vehicle for a great man, be aware that while his life is already over, the party is just starting....

6. How to Become a Successful Artist
Becoming a successful artist requires two things: great art great marketing. If you are like me then you’ll feel more comfortable with the “great art” side of things rather than the “great marketing”. When I first started out I like most emerging artists thought that if I produce truly beautiful works of art, that are challenging and unique, galleries would snap them up. I found out that most galleries are willing to look at you until you have a list of s...

7. Gunnery Sergeant John Basilone: One Man Army
A US Navy destroyer is named after him, as well as a bridge, football field, and two sections of highways. The U.S. Postal Service honored him with a stamp. His hometown erected a magnificent life-size bronze statue and each September they host a parade in his honor. Locally, a plaque bears his name at the U.S. Navy Memorial. Called a “a one-man army” by General Douglas MacArthur, he remains the only Marine in World War II to earn the Purple Heart, the Navy Cross and the Congressional Medal of Honor. He was a wa...

8. Dominic Salvatore Gentile: Ace of Aces
Variously called "a one-man Air Force," "Captain Courageous," and "the Ace of Aces," Captain Dominic Gentile had few peers when it came to air combat. Along with his close friend and dedicated wingman, John T. Godfrey, their lethal partnership so plagued Hermann Goring's Luftwaffe during World War II that they earned the epithet, "Debden Gangsters." In early 1944, Gentile shot down his 27th enemy fighter, surpassing World War I ace Eddie Rickenbacker’s record of 26 combat victories. He w...

9. Guru: a Spiritual Master
Definition of a Guru or an evolved spiritual guide There are various aspects to the Supreme God Principle. These various aspects of God perform specific functions in the Universe. This is pretty much akin to the government of any country which has various departments to facilitate the smooth governing and functioning of the country as a whole. Just as we have a department for education in a government, which facilitates teaching of modern sciences throughout the country, the aspect of God that looks after spiri...

10. Postmodernism as an artistic space. The photographic world of Chezhin the artist
Black and white photography (and, latterly, colour photography) always emphasises the dividing line marking the intersection between time(s) and space(s), the intersection and interpenetration of today and yesterday, today and tomorrow - of my life and someone else’s. It points to the event experienced by a person (someone we know or don’t know, myself, just someone, nature, or society as a whole) at the moment when my attention is directed at the rectangular frame recording that which has already been and gone and which ...