Mutual Funds Performance Comparisons

written by: Tim Stawman; article published: year 2008, month 05;


  

In: Categories » Legal and finance » Stocks and mutual funds » Mutual Funds Performance Comparisons

It is obviously important when considering the performance of a mutual fund to measure its performance correctly. It is also critical to make fair comparisons and judgments both in terms of time and benchmarks.

Consider the Strong Growth Fund, a $2.8 billion no-load fund in the large-cap growth category. This fund had a return of 75 percent for 1999 and –9 percent in 2000: How did this fund perform? On average, over the two years, it had a return of [(+75 –9) /2], or 33 percent, a seemingly outstanding performance. However, we need to analyze this in more detail:

  1. It outperformed the market in 1999 but not in 2000. In 1999, the market was up, but nothing like 75 percent, and in 2000 the market was down about the same as this fund.

  2. It outperformed its peer group for these two years, with a differential of +36 percent in 1999 and +4 percent in 2000.

  3. On a three-year basis it outperformed both its peer group (13 percent vs. 6 percent), and the S&P 500 Index (13 percent vs. 5 percent).

  4. On a five-year basis, it outperformed its peer group (14 percent vs. 13 percent), but not the S&P 500 Index (14 percent vs. 16 percent).

As we look at this fund in more detail, we find it had a spectacular performance in 1999, with a 75 percent return. Is this likely to happen again? The odds are clearly very low for this or any other fund to accomplish such a feat again. It was a spectacular year in 1999 for many funds and investors because of the overheated technology market—such a year may be a once-in-a-lifetime event.

It is interesting to note that this fund had an average (1998–2000) calculated turnover ratio for its portfolio of 313 percent, an astounding amount by any standard. Much of this trading appears to have been successful, given the returns and the comparisons to Strong Growth's peer group.

As we shall see later, taxable gains for a mutual fund can be a strong detriment for shareholders. In Strong's case, with so much turnover, it is clearly generating considerable gains and losses. In fact, Strong does not compare well to industry standards with regard to tax efficiency and it is probably best suited for a tax-deferred retirement account.

Then we come to the five-year comparisons. Strong Growth has not been in operation long enough for a 10-year comparison. Although Strong Growth bested its peers, on average, over this five-year period, it did not beat the S&P 500 Index. Thus, an investment in an S&P 500 Index fund would have been superior, at much greater tax efficiency, and with lower costs.

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. ECNs ~ It`s Not Your Grandfather`s Market Anymore
Recent changes in SEC regulations and technology have transformed how investors interact with the stock market. I explain these changes in the following sections, and I show you how these changes enable online investors to make more money on their investments. In the following sections, you gain an understanding of what happens after you click your mouse button to execute an online trade. You also discover how you can avoid hidden transaction costs by using an electronic communications network (ECN) and how you benefit from ECNs ...

  

2. Mutual Fund Basics
Over the years, the stock market has outperformed any other investment. Unlike a mutual fund, however, individual investors frequently can’t purchase a large number of different securities to diversify their investment risk. Buying shares in a mutual fund solves this problem. When you invest in a mutual fund, the diversity of the portfolio reduces the risk of losing your total investment. Selecting the right fund may be difficult, but you can find plenty of online help. Assume that you have $1,000 to inves...

3. How to Screen Mutual Funds Online
The Internet provides a variety of mutual fund screening tools that sort thousands of mutual funds by criteria that you select. For example, you may want one type of fund for your children’s education — something long term because you don’t need the money for 10 to 20 years — and a different fund for your retirement to help you reduce your current tax liabilities. With these online screening tools, you can evaluate several funds that meet your financial needs. Most of the stock-screenin...

4. Advantages and Disadvantages of Mutual Funds
As a general rule, the first palce to start analyzing a fund is by by comparing its expense ratio to similar funds. All funds have fees and expenses, but the amounts vary. In addition to sales and redemption fees, the mutual fund’s prospectus indicates the fund’s management and administration expenses. The fund’s investment advisor generally receives 0.5 to 1.0 percent of the fund’s average daily net assets. Administrative expenses include legal, auditing, and accounting costs, along with the f...

5. Buying Mutual Funds Online Using an Online Broker
You have many choices in how you purchase mutual funds. In addition to purchasing directly from the mutual fund company, you can purchase mutual funds through registered representatives of banks, trust companies, stockbrokers, discount brokers, and financial planners. To purchase mutual funds via the Internet, go to an online broker’s Web site. (I list a few examples later in this section.) Register by completing the online application form. You have to provide the same information you normally provide f...

6. What you have to know to determine the fair value of a stock and the right price
You can use several methods to determine the fair value of a stock. Throughout the following sections, I discuss three of the more popular methods of determining the right price for a stock: Fundamental analysis Technical analysis Market timing Valuing securities is important to your financial health. Stocks are more difficult to value than bonds. Bonds have a limited life and a stated payment rate. Common stocks don’t have a limi...

7. Researching a Company`s SEC Filing
In the United States, publicly traded companies are required to file business and financial information with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These reports are entered into a government-sponsored database called EDGAR (www.sec.gov), which stands for Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval. The SEC’s EDGAR service provides downloadable data that can be accessed by individual investors. You also can save SEC reports on a disk and read them at a later time. One disadvantage of this free ser...

8. How to Choose the Best Stock for the Right Goal
Selecting your own stocks can be hard work. The exciting thing is that the Internet has much of the information you need, and most of this information is free. With the power of your computer, you can utilize Internet data to gain real insight. As you start to determine which stocks you’re interested in, you should be aware of the different types of stocks. Stocks have distinct characteristics, and as general economic conditions change, they behave in special ways. Write a short list of your financia...