In: Categories » Business » Management » Evaluating Proposed Projects
|
Evaluating proposed projects tests the spirit and limits of the new manager in taking on new challenges. The extent of the challenge depends on whether the proposed project falls within the discipline and experience of the manager or involves a number of unfamiliar disciplines. The challenge also depends on whether the project can be completed solely in the manager's unit or involves other groups. It's not uncommon for a project manager to become involved in a different discipline. This is also true of small projects. Any project manager involved in developing a new product/service or making improvements or changes to an existing product/service will deal not only with technology, marketing, and sales but also with all the support functions. New disciplines and involvement of other units complicate the evaluation. Consider the process for evaluating a project proposal submitted by some member of your department. The evaluation process as suggested here applies to all proposals that span the continuum from research to implementation of any project, related to any discipline, and in any organization be it academia, government, industry, or not-for-profit organizations. Assume that the proposal you recently received involves integrating the activities of several subunits within the organization. This complicates the evaluation process, but few proposals involve only a single subunit. What are the options? You basically have three options: (1) scan the proposal and disregard it because you have more important priorities; (2) do a cursory review and reject it; or (3) read the proposal to gain some understanding, ask for additional clarification, and then make a decision to pursue or not pursue the effort. Choosing option 1 will send the message "Don't bother me, I have more to think about than considering something new." Such actions will stop the flow of anything that may be outside the routine day-to-day work. Option 2, the negative response, requires face-to-face discussion. You can't communicate negative decisions via e-mails or memos regardless of subject. Even though you may not support the proposal, through that face-to-face discussion you provide your reasons and show your interest in accepting unsolicited proposals. If you choose option 3, which gives you an opportunity to ask for additional or explanatory information, you send the message that you're interested, you're available, and a very positive message of who you are; you not only talk about supporting new ideas, you welcome them. Discussions within any of the three options clarify requirements and often lead to restructuring or enhancement of the original proposal. Making decisions based solely on the written word without that face-to-face opportunity for clarifying issues often leads to forfeiting future opportunities. The process for evaluating a proposal involves asking a series of questions that allow you to understand the scope of work and its potential for meeting the organization's established criteria for pursuing new projects. Think back to your experiences before you became a manager. Remember how many times the work had to be redone because the scope was never clearly defined, scope creep never ended, intergroup and functional requirements were never fully resolved, and the complexities of the project were never fully identified. Think about how much time was spent on rework and not only the cost but also the customer dissatisfaction that was generated in the process. Assuming that the proposal includes the basic information required to make a decision, consider asking the following questions:
Another approach is to consider a generic set of questions: What does the proposal accomplish? Why and why not should the organizational unit take on this challenge? How will the terms of this challenge be fulfilled? Who takes responsibility for meeting the objectives? When will this effort take place? Where will the work be done? How will performance be measured?
|
legal disclaimer
1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service
Useful tools and features
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.
related articles
Let’s look at the difference between managing and leading. The two terms are sometimes used interchangeably—such as when people refer to someone in a management position as a leader—but there are important distinctions. The difference between managing and leading is the difference between doing things right versus doing the right things. Doing things right means being efficient. Doing the right things means being effective. Sales leaders are efficient when they get quotes and other work...
|
|
The two things that salespeople must do are to sell and to keep customers happy. It’s not complicated, but it’s not easy. One of my assignments while at AT&T involved designing a sales competency model. We wanted some way of assuring ourselves that our salespeople could sell effectively. We wanted to know we could relied on them to consistently deliver results that we and customers wanted. We were especially concerned about preventing mistakes by identifying the skills or knowledge they needed ahead of time....
3. Economic Incentives when creating a company
One of the critical attributes of the value creating company is the degree of attention paid to providing appropriate near-term and long-term incentives to its managers and employees. There should be a true causeand- effect phenomenon surrounding incentives and results. If a company’s incentives are based on some of the common, broad accounting measures such as return on equity, or return on assets, or even earnings per share, there is a real risk that decisions, large and small, will suffer from the economic disc...
4. Management Philosophy Choices Practices and Actions
Management Philosophy The company’s management pursues the hologram philosophy whereby each employee is a replica of the whole and understands management’s visions and the company’s daily business situation and long-term strategy. That allows employees to make independent decisions to implement corporate strategy, while taking into account short-term tradeoffs, broad business implications, and other consequences. The management recognizes that people are “incredibly ...
5. General errors and mistakes that commited by Business Companies
Companies have worked hard at restructuring themselves in response to the dramatic changes that have occurred in the economy and in their marketplaces in recent years. Here are a few thoughts concerning some of the serious errors companies have committed in their efforts to change: Mistake 1: Laying Off Only Lower-Level Support Staff Personnel decisions are made by senior and middle management— who, of course, are not going to choose themselves for outplacement. As a result, the company ends up ...
6. Risk Assessment Form
Purpose Risk assessment forms are used to capture outputs from the risk management process so that key stakeholders are aware of both risks identified and the evaluations thereof. Some risk assessment forms are built with risk mitigation information as well, so as to track the responses and the outcomes of those responses. The risk assessment form is a component of a comprehensive risk archive. They may stand alone or be a component of a project status report. Application Risk assessment forms ...
7. Work Results
Purpose Work results are the output of any project effort. The documentation for work results is a record that the effort has been completed and the output has been produced. It is used as proof that the effort was put forth. As with technical documents, work results are used for a wide variety of purposes associated with the varied nature of the work that was completed. Application Documentation from work results is used as affirmation that work has been accomplished as prescribed. If work was...
8. Strategy Innovation Is Managing Your Business Toward the Future
Organizations that have found it difficult to focus on managing the future business provide a range of excuses, including: Corporate myopia Industry turbulence Future incompetence Corporate Myopia There are some companies that are so engrossed in managing today’s business that they claim they cannot find the time or energy to think about tomorrow. We recently asked the senior management team of a billion-dollar corporation to speculate on the com- ...
9. Press Release
Purpose A press release is issued to provide public awareness on an issue of importance to the organization. It serves as a formal expression of the organization’s stance on that issue, and frequently provides commentary from someone in the upper echelons of the organizational hierarchy. It may be in response to environmental conditions affecting the organization or may be initiated to promote the organization’s perspective. Application Press releases are used to encourage favorable media ...
10. Ten follow`up letters when selling a product
Don't underestimate the power of the humble thank-you note. Thank-you notes clearly indicate to the recipients that you've made an effort to think about them and thank them for their support. Consider the last time you received a handwritten invitation or note of thanks. Feels good, doesn't it? You can use thank-you notes for a variety of occasions. They confirm your commitment and help solidify your business relationship, making it more difficult for your competitors to replace you. Use handwritten notes for just about any situa...