Coming Out and Positive Images

written by: Leen Karnego; article published: year 2008, month 11;



In: Categories » » Politics and society » Coming Out and Positive Images

Do the courts protect "coming out" speech?

Sometimes. The law is still very much in a developing state. As more and more lesbian and gay Americans choose to be open about their lives and seek not only tolerance but support for the relationships they form with partners, there will inevitably be more "coming out" speech to employers, coworkers, landlords, neighbors, and others. When the employer, landlord, or other party is a government agency, the Constitution should forbid imposing any penalty as a result of coming out. But because the law is not settled as to this important principle, it is imperative that, if possible, a lawyer's advice be sought in advance if there is reason to believe that honesty will lead to any form of government reprisal.

Is "coming out" speech considered political speech?

Sometimes. In 1979 the California Supreme Court suggested that a person's affirmation of homosexuality was analogous to the expression of a political point of view and could be protected by a California state labor law that prohibited all employers from interfering with the political activities of employees. 35 Since then, the California state attorney general has formally adopted that interpretation of the state labor code.36 Thus, coming out speech probably cannot be the basis of a firing in the state of California.

Federal court cases, however, have yielded mixed results. One federal appeals court invalidated the firing of a county employee based on his Gayinforming his boss that he was gay and that he intended to speak as a citizen to the county commissioners on the subject of civil rights for lesbians and gay men. The court found that the speech was protected and that firing the employee because of his speech was unconstitutional.37 In the Acanfora case discussed above, the press interviews, which included avowals of the teacher's own homosexuality, were found not to justify firing him (although his firing was permitted on other grounds).38 A third, more recent case, reached the opposite conclusion. This case involved a school guidance counselor who was fired after she told her supervisor she was bisexual; the court ruled that such information is purely personal and thus not analogous to political speech and not protected under the Constitution.39 The differing results of these cases may be reconciled by treating the first two as involving what is more traditionally thought of as political speechi.e., addressing the county commissioners or speaking to the pressin addition to the coming out statement. The third case, on the other hand, involves coming out in a one-on-one conversation with a supervisor. Regardless, coming out speech ought to be recognized by the courts as political expression.

What are agency officials likely to claim in an attempt to fire a person who publicly affirms her or his homosexuality?

Several of the most disturbing cases have turned on the question of whether a lesbian or gay employee's actions amounted to "flaunting" homosexuality. A federal court of appeals decision in 1971 upheld the refusal of the University of Minnesota to employ a gay man as head of the university library's cataloging division on the ground that his "personal conduct, as represented in the public and University news media, [wa]s not consistent with the best interest of the university." 40 The applicant had sought a marriage license to marry another man, and the event had received much publicity. A strikingly similar case also involved a person who had tried to obtain legal recognition of gay marriage. Here, a gay activist who worked as a clerk typist for a federal agency was also fired after a highly publicized attempt to reform the marriage laws of the state of Washington. A federal appeals court (including Judge, now Supreme Court Justice, Anthony Kennedy) upheld the firing on the ground that government's interest in maintaining public confidence in the agency outweighed the employee's interest in "publicly flaunting and broadcasting his homosexual activities."41 The federal government changed its policy after the case was decided, but the degree of the court's hostility to the gay plaintiff indicates the difficulty that even seemingly clear constitutional claims may face. Although these cases now seem dated, they have not yet been clearly overruled.

In anticipation of such an argument by an employer, it is extremely important to document that advocacy of lesbian.and gay rights has no adverse impact on how a person functions on the job or on how the agency functions.

Can public transit and other state entities that accept advertising dealing with social or political issues refuse to accept advertising from gay rights organizations?

No. When a public transportation authority accepts other advertisements espousing political and social concerns, it creates a public forum, and access to such a public forum could be limited only by precise, clear regulations concerning time, place, and manner of speech. Access to such a forum may not he barred because gay rights views may be unpopular.42

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. APPLICATION OF THE METHODS OF QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
APPLICATION OF THE METHODS OF QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS FOR ANALYSING OF THE POLICE OF THE REPUBLIC OF HUNGARY The decision of the Council of European Ministers of 21 November 1994 relating to the industrial competitiveness of the European Union has approved the motion concerning the elaboration of the quality development policy [1]. According to the approved motion the importance and extension of the quality view should be recognised in the field of both private and state service. "The competitiveness of Europe depends...

2. The New Consumer: Three Possible Scenarios
Consumption patterns are greatly influenced by purchasing power, which has risen globally, but most acutely in emerging markets. Future global economic growth will significantly influence the levels of wealth and purchasing power among consumers in different countries, as well as the continued spread of technological use among consumers. But the direction and speed of this growth between now and 2015 remain uncertain, since the rise and fall of economic cycles ultimately depend on how other macro factors unfold. ...

3. Barriers at the Frontiers of Science
Government intervention is being felt throughout the economy, from basic manufacturing to the most sophisticated telecommunications services. Nowhere is the effect stronger than at the frontiers of science and technology, where a host of new discoveries and developments is confounding existing regulations and rendering old ways of doing business irrelevant. Competing technical standards are on the rise and new ethical quandaries seem to be popping up everywhere, giving rise to increasingly complex regulatory issu...

4. Possible Scenarios of Regulation and Activism in the Context of Globalization
How regulatory patterns unfold in the future will be determined by how corporations respond to the new dynamics of regulation and activism emerging today. Companies already manage a diverse array of constituents, including governments, nongovernmental organizations, consumers, and the public, in addition to their own shareholders. As such, value-building companies that find creative ways to address broad social concerns and cooperate with interest groups may be better positioned for future success than those with...

5. Managing Water Scarcity
Dealing with water scarcity will require several actors and multiple solutions. One recommendation is to apply the market-based approach used with other commodities. An eight-ounce glass of water can be refilled for 2500 times less than the cost of a can of soft drink. Under these conditions, consumers have little incentive to conserve. A 1998 survey by the American Water Works Association indicates that 33 percent of the 60,000 public water systems in the United States encourage waste by offering volume discount...

6. Neighbourhood Management: Taking Involvement Further
The basis for the emphasis on community involvement must be that of effectiveness rather than sentimentality. At present local community interests are represented though Local Strategic Partnerships which draw together local public, voluntary and business sectors and take decisions about priorities and funding for neighbourhood renewal (such as the use of the Neighbourhood Renewal Fund). However, there are differences in the effectiveness of such groups nationally and in the balance of power held by the different representativ...

7. Rapid change in neighbourhoods and communities
Growth Management is a technique most associated with the tourism industry, however it is clear that it is relevant to areas of fast growth in other environments where there is dynamic change. We are keen to employ our knowledge and skills to assist you in using GMP in your organisation, with your communities. As more tourism resorts have appreciated the need to manage the balance between tourists and local people, so new management techniques were needed which reflected a greater respect for the role of local communities in ...

8. Cities; culture and regeneration
There is now a growing realisation that the look and feel of a place is critically important to its development and regeneration. There has been a proliferation of cultural projects in the last few decades, increasing in number and magnitude. This has been accompanied by the increasing importance of symbols such as the award of ‘European Capital of Culture’ or the Olympics. By differentiating themselves from each other by the presence of large cultural projects, cities such as Barcelona, Frankfurt and Birmi...

9. Social Insecurity
Without question, the greatest challenges confronting countries with graying populations are the escalating costs of funding pensions and providing affordable healthcare. Most social security systems throughout the developed world operate on a pay-as-you-go basis—a system of transfers whereby workers support retirees by paying out a percentage of their earnings in the form of payroll taxes. The system was perfectly suited to the demographic patterns of the previous century, when growing populations, large f...

10. The Myth of the Global Consumer
If there was ever a golden age in which mass marketing was all companies needed to reach homogenous markets and predictable consumers, it is long gone. Traditional brand management systems, pioneered by Procter & Gamble, were very successful in the 1950s and 1960s. Theodore Levitt, emeritus professor at the Harvard Business School, pushed the idea of the virtues of mass marketing to new heights in his famous 1983 article, “The Globalization of Markets.” In it, he wrote: “Different cultural pr...