Clip On Test Versus Whole Board Functional Test

written by: Sukumar; article published: year 2007, month 07;



In: Categories » Electronics and communication » Electronic products » Clip On Test Versus Whole Board Functional Test

In-circuit functional testing (or clip-on testing as it is popularly called) is best described as testing the functionality of each component on the board using test clips. Here, the inference is that the overall board functionality can be verified if each and every component on the board is tested and found to be good.

Clip-on testing uses a technique called backdriving to force the desired logic state to the input pins of the device under test (DUT). The tester hardware is equipped with powerful pin drivers that can source or sink currents upto a maximum of around 600mA to do the node-forcing. Of course, this is done for a very short amount of time to ensure that the tests done are within the safety limits.

Whole Board Functional testing, on the other hand, is characterized by powering up the board and the application of input stimuli and measurement of the output signals on the whole board (usually through pins on the edge connector). The measured output is compared against an expected result from a Known Good Board already stored in the database. This is aimed at verifying the functionality of the entire board. Here, there is no need to test individual components on the board. The entire board is taken as a single device and tested.

Limitations of clip on testing as compared to Whole Board testing

  1. In Clip on testing, the Ics are tested only for its functionality. It is assumed that if all the components on the board are good, the board should work when put in the machine. The track connectivity between the components on a board are not checked. Although the links between the pins of the DUT are tested during clip on test, the interlinks between the various components on the board as well as to the edge connectors are not tested. If, due to spillage, corrosion, or rework, a track fault exists, this fault cannot be traced using the clip on test method. Where as, in whole board test, since the input/output signals are driven/sensed from the edge connector, any track opens/shorts will be easily detected.
  1. Let us look at another example, where the PCB is faulty because of a low impedance of around 50ohms w.r.t. GND at one of the input pins of an IC. In clip on test technique, since the tester hardware is driving this faulty input pin, its powerful pindrivers (that can source & sink currents upto a max. of 600ma.) can easily drive the required Test patterns to this input pin during test and declare the IC as good. But when this test is carried out through the edge connector during whole board test, the board fails, as the output stage of the previous IC will be unable to drive the required current to override the low impedance fault. Thus using the whole Board Test, faults can be zeroed in on much quickly and efficiently.
  1. Testing a device in-circuit can be a time consuming affair. It could take upto a day to test all ICs and the passive components one by one. Whole board testing is much faster as the complete functionality of the board is tested in one go, in a matter of minutes.
  1. Clip on testing is meant for testing boards for which there is limited data. For Whole board testing, availability of complete schematic diagram is necessary. Developing whole board test program is done after understanding the complete working of the PCB. The program developed would then fully test all the functions. Special Test jigs are to be developed for each type of board. The effort to develop the test program is only once, but the number of boards that can be recovered by the use of this methodology of test is large and in quick time.
  1. Using Whole Board testing method more number of boards can be made serviceable compared to the clip on method. The test time is reduced and board serviceability percentage increases manyfold.

Written By: Sukumar
Website: Estec

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. Learn to troubleshoot with an Ohm meter. Save money and do it yourself!
Checking resistance is very simple once you know the basics, and it can save you time and money spent to hire an expensive electrician. Resistance is measured in units called Ohms. Let’s start by explaining exactly what an Ohm check is. By definition an Ohm is: The unit of measurement used to measure resistance to electrical current. Here is an easy way to explain it:electricity is like water flowing through a pipe, and resistance is anything that blocks the water from flowing. Basically, an Ohm ...

2. Why do we need a portable players
Telephones and Stereos are no talk of tomorrow. They have just been replaced by their portable and more compatible versions like cell phones, mp3 players and mp4 players. The basic concept of these portable gadgets is also the same, but their supremacy over their predecessors lies in them being small, fashionable and relatively cheaper for a common man. So the Basic Question in discussion is why to use these gadgets. Music is said to be the food for the soul and this food is which many have become deprived to due to their work...

3. How Easy to Upload Music Files to Your MP3 MP4 Player!
The people ask me one question frequently: How can i upload music to my brand new mp3 player? Well , for some of you guys and galls , this is easy question. But there are peoples for which it is difficult to progress. Here i will try to explain this process - concisely. Ok , so , if you buy your mp3 player from the store or online and the device is brand new, you must have a box. Where is your new player of course and some other important things. Those things are: Installation CD , USB cable , earphones, recharger and ma...

4. Tips for Purchasing Electronic Test and Measurement Equipment
When obtaining Test and Measurement Equipment there are many factors involved in the decision making process. Below are some considerations to assist you in making a favorable buying decision. The categories for purchasing T&M equipment can be considered as follows: New, Used and Refurbished. * New equipment requires minimal functional consideration other than “is it suitable for the application?” New equipment is obviously the highest priced choice and in some cases may have long delivery or &ldq...

5. Losing Data from a Digital Camera
Photo cameras have been around for over one and a half century now and really revolutionized the way we capture images of the world. While in days gone by a painter would take weeks and months to painstakingly and meticulously paint a portrait or landscape to make it as realistic as possible, with the coming of the cameras, extremely realistic images of real-world objects could be created simply at the touch of a button. The cameras became widely popular within a few decades of their invention and they are still the rage. ...

6. How to download games on your PSP
The PSP is one of the best systems you can use for portable entertainment. Yet in some respects, it is not as portable as it could be. Why? Well, to run the system, you must use a UMD disc, the main means of storing PSP games and movies. While the UMD discs are very small, but they are still a hindrance to follow, especially if you have a good number of them. In fact, if you have too many UMDs, you must obtain a package of fiscal large enough to contain everything. This can take the road if you're the type who wants to keep the PSP in...

7. Tissue Culture Microscopes
Microscopes are important tools in the world of science, technology, biology, chemistry, and physics, and almost every branch of science that requires the expertise of a microscope. Among the necessity that requires the need of a microscope is the fact that certain minute organisms are never visible in the eye of a human, thus, the need for  microscope is very much high. In this case, the place of microscope in the heart of everyone is very much indispensable and no wonder, no...

8. Cooking with a Solar Cooker
When can the Global Sun Oven® be used? Like all solar cookers, the Global Sun Oven requires direct sunlight to function properly. So it is important to use the solar oven on bright days in locations where there is no shade or shadows. The Global Sun Oven can be used summer or winter. What is important is the brightness of the day, not the outside air temperature. This solar cooker has been used very successfully at the base camp of a Mt. Everest expedition where the temperatures were often well below zero. The...