Art Education in America, Why Art Graduates Still Can\'t Draw or Paint

written by: eric hines; article published: year 2008, month 09;



In: Categories » Education and reference » University and college » Art Education in America, Why Art Graduates Still Can't Draw or Paint

You may or may not be aware of the decline in art education in the last 70 years. If you are unaware, believe me it's been in a steady decline.

I have the pleasure of working with Larry Gluck, Founder of Mission: Renaissance, the world's largest fine art program, who has himself been in the fine arts for quite some time.

From apprenticing with Picaso's old class mate portrait master Giuseppe Trotta, to graduating from the Pratt Institute, to producing and selling over 3,000 of his works of art, to creating his unique method of instruction - The Gluck Method - which is currently being taught to more than 3,000 students every week at Mission: Renaissance studios in California and Canada.

Point being, Larry knows art.

We see the results of the decline of our Nation's art education programs everyday. You would not believe the number of art teacher applicants who come to us with a degree in the fine arts who yet express their frustration with the lack of drawing and painting skills they acquired in school.

I had a discussion with Larry Gluck a few weeks ago about the decline of education in the field of the arts, primarily the visual fine arts, ie; drawing, oil painting, watercolor, sculpture, etc.

Here are the 5 points that Larry pointed out in aforementioned discussion that are spear heading the decline in fine art education in America.

1. The if-it-feels-good-then-go-this-it brand of art istruction.

This is one of the main reasons behind the Bachelor of Fine Art or Visual Arts graduate not being able to draw or paint anything aside from abstract art.

I was telling Larry how many times in high school and college I ran into the "same" art teacher. They seem to be cast from the same mold! They wear birkenstocks, they are super supportive towards anything you put on a canvas, if you SNEEZE on the canvas it is a wondrous expression of art, yet they crush any hopes you have for actually making it as a fine artist.

While this may have the short term benefit of making a new student feel warm and fuzzy in the inside for a short period of time, it has the long term detriment of not teaching any fundamentals and basics in the visual arts to the art student. The basics like value, perspective, line drawing and color are all but extinct in the classrooms today.

I would not consider it such a sleight of hand if the
classes were more descriptively labeled. Instead of 'Life Drawing' or 'Fine Art 101' they should properly be named, 'Abstract Painting', Feel Good About Drawing', and 'Arts and Crafts.'.'

If the student asks a question on how to make their still-life look more real they are given airy-fairy nonsense, like, "if it feels good then go with it". or "what you draw is your very own unique interpretation."

Quite simply put, this is not a workable method of teaching the arts, nor will it produce an artist who can actually paint or draw realistically.

2. The "give it to me now" mindset of society.

We reside on a planet where instant gratification is king. No need to cultivate our own food, there happens to be 4 groceries stores in walking distance, not that we would walk of course, and there is Burger King right down the street in case we are not in the mood to cook...again. Want to loose weight? Never mind exercising, liposuction will take care of that for you!

You get the point. The same point of view frequently trips ups the art student.

You see the Masters like DaVinci and Michaelangelo actually worked to become a master. There did not happen to be a convenient four year degree college where a student of the arts picked up the cost of the school with a low interest payment differed student loan, took some art classes, bought highly detailed anatomy and art books, and then had lunch at the student cafeteria.

They made their own paint. They worked for years as apprentices just to have the opportunity to watch their master in action for a moment or to receive the occasional pointer.

No quality books on anatomy were readily available to the determined artists. The solution? Purchase a cadaver, dissect it, and learn anatomy thus. Then translate that knowledge onto a canvas.

Learning how to draw and paint is very rewarding. It doesn't take a lifetime and yes, you can learn - even if you "can't draw a straight line.All that is really required is the proper instruction
delivered by a caring and able teacher.

3. The importance of art and the role the artist plays is not as valued in our society has it needs to be, and this is especially true in the field of education.

Why is art so important? To start us off here is some data based on statistics;

Per the 'Champions of Change, the Impact of the Arts on Learning' study; - 82.6% of 8th graders who were involved heavily in fine arts earned mostly A's and B's, versus 67.2% who were not.

- Students who are not heavily involved in fine arts have more than double the chance of dropping out of school by the 10th grade.

This is only a small bit of information in this eye opening study. And what does are all wise and knowing education system do? They cut the Arts budgets! The field of art, the educating of the artist, and the fundamental teachings of the fine arts are just not being viewed with the importance they deserve, that importance being the building of the future society and culture.

I am not trying to sound profound or over the top, but if you sit down and seriously take a good look at this concept, you will see its Importance. Art is the very fabric of which society and culture are sewn! Think of ancient Rome, Greece, Modern day China, America. All these societies were/are a reflection of their art and artists.

What kind of culture are we building with a half-measure art education system, unworkable teaching methods, or worse yet, none at all due to budget cuts. An artist is magnificently vital in creating our future, however we are failing to educate our artists!

4. "The Talent Myth," that one must be born with the ability to draw and paint.

The talent myth pervades society and it's learning facilities. That talent is a "gift" handed down from some lofty cloud, or it's in your genes, or the planets were perfectly aligned when creative souls were born. Name for me one other field where this is the pre-requisite.

In discussing this Larry tells us three things;

First, that every thing has a technology to it, if you learn the basics and fundamentals to it, and practice it, you can do it.

Second, after teaching art for over 30 years - currently with more than 3,000 students enrolled - I can tell you that "The Talent Myth" is exactly that - a myth. I can also bring to your awareness that a very large population of art teachers are either buying into the talent myth or really do not have an inkling how to go about teaching the average student how to draw or paint.

Third: When "these bastions of art" tell someone, from their ivory tower of authority, that one cannot succeed in the arts due to lack of talent, it becomes very hard for the individual to overcome this. It basically sits on one's ingrained fear of failure and thus another potential artist is ruined.

If an art instructor, teacher, school administrator, parent, sibling or "friend" has ever told you, your child, or a loved one that you do not have the talent to become an artist, let alone an excellent one, they have mislead you. There is still hope.

A brain surgeon was not innately born with the natural ability to just to casually walk in and start operating on a brain with no formal training. They spent years in school, studying hard, interning for years, and learned the basics of brain surgery and thus could eventually become a successful neurosurgeon.

The same concept works for the artist. But it need not take years.

5. Schools and art teachers are not producing a real product when teaching.

One would expect that after taking art classes in college for 4 years and spending tens of thousands of dollars or more on tuition that one would be able to draw and paint like a pro.

As previously mentioned, we happen to have a high number of graduates in the field of art that seek employment with us as an art teacher, however their basic drawing and painting abilities leave much to be desired!

The art school and teachers have not produce the product in their students that they have been paid for. How did this come to be so widely acceptable in the field of the arts? One may find this almost criminal.

This is usually the result of the teachers who either don't know the fundamentals of the visual arts, or who are unwilling or are unable to provide them to the student.

How do we know this to be true? Often we will run across a graduate who applies for an art instructor position, but whose skills in the arts are not very impressive. However the potential employee exhibits a good demeanor and an enthusiastic persona.

When hired, and put through our training program they, for the first time, really learn how to draw and paint. This is not our claim, but that of the student. In a matter of months they are not only able to draw and paint beautifully, they can and do successfully instruct others in how to do the same!

There you have all five reasons why art and education is declining in America. Hopefully you can use this information to help you and those you love in their artistic aspirations.


Eric Hines has had the pleasure to work in the field of the arts for more than a decade. He has owned an art gallry in Los Angeles and has been a working musician. Currently he is an executive and enjoys doing his part in helping over 3,000 art students lLearn to draw and paint every week at Mission: Renaissance.

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. Why Instructional Designers Should Study Theories of Learning
Ultimately, articulating your philosophy of education helps you describe how you feel about learning, but philosophies don’t provide guidelines for creating learning programs. That’s where learning theories come in. Learning theories explain predictable relationships. In the field of learning, theories usually describe a relationship between communicating content and the outcomes of learning (often indicating a link between the presentation of learning material in a particular type of situation and h...

2. Term Paper
Term paper is one of the major vehicles of judging a student's grasp on a particular topic or subject. Instead of being busy day and night writing a term paper if the student pays attention to a few simple tips he can excel in writing it. If writing is not perceived as a daunting task but a way of putting forward one's viewpoint in paper then writing the term paper can be a highly fulfilling experience. Term paper writing becomes easy if the student has the habit of reading. Until and unless one is a good reader, his thought p...

3. Maintaining a Healthy Attitude towards Doing Dissertations
Dissertation: it can be a very daunting, scary and intimidating word. College students are shaken by the very word. Unfortunately, students can not do away with dissertations, no matter what their course is and no matter what college or university they are attending. It is usually the last big requirement during the senior year before finally getting that hard-earned diploma.   A dissertation is different from other college paper requirements. So being a good writer alone will not assure you of a Grade A+. What dif...

4. Getting Dissertation Help
You are on your way to finally getting that hard-earned diploma - your ticket to a successful career and a better life. However, you have to overcome one more big challenge before officially being proclaimed a new graduate-your dissertation. Finishing your dissertation is no easy task. It is time-consuming and very challenging, if not exhausting, physically, mentally, psychologically and yes, even financially. And despite this seemingly daunting task, it is imperative for you to turn in a good dissertation in order to graduate...

5. Assignment
An assignment is a piece of work that has been appointed to a person. Also known as homework, an assignment refers to a task assigned to students by their teachers to be completed mostly outside of class. Teachers assign homework for many reasons. The assignment can help you review and practice what you've covered in class; get ready for the next day's class; learn to use resources, such as libraries, reference materials and the Internet to find information about a subject; explore subjects more fully than classroom time permit...

6. Studying In Germany
The face of racism in Germany More and more Nepalese are coming to Germany for studies these days. Although English speaking nations like the United States and the United Kingdom are top destination as yet, Germany is picking up rapidly. German institutions are renowned in the world for their state of the art educational facilities and academic excellence. And a handful of Nepalese have already made their way to being recognized as top-class students in Germany. Getting access to German...

7. Law School Essay
In the past few decades, there has been an explosion in the number of people applying for admission to law schools. A lot of this increase is the result of more and more women and minorities pursuing a legal career. But this means it’s tougher than ever to get into law school these days, as not nearly enough new law schools have been created to meet the huge increase in competition for admission to law school. So not only do you have to have an excellent academic profile to be admitted to law school, you’ve also got to write ...

8. 4 Steps to Write Career research paper
Writing a career research paper is one of the best subjects to choose for preparing term papers. This is because opting for this subject not only helps in academic period but can also provide a complete knowledge for pursuing a career in a specialized field. Drafting out paper in career studies also helps a student to prioritize his goals and acknowledging his goals in life as well. It can be stepping stones for the students to specialize in the particular field and helps him in his/her higher studies as well. The student can choose h...