Advantages and Disadvantages of Tape Backup Drives

written by: Joe Karaka; article published: year 2006, month 11;


In: Categories » Computers and technology » Storage devices » Advantages and Disadvantages of Tape Backup Drives

Advantages of Tape Backup Drives Although tape backup drives are no longer the one-size-fits-all panacea for all types of bigger-than-floppy storage problems, they have their place in keeping your data safe. Following are several good reasons for using tape backup drives:

  • Tape backups are a true one-cartridge backup process for individual client PCs, standalone computers, or network servers when high-capacity tape drives and cartridges are used. Anytime multiple tapes or disks must be used to make a backup, the chances of backup failure increase.

  • If you or your company has made previous backup tapes, you must keep a tape drive to access that data or perform a restore from it. Tape backup drives are necessary if you need to restore from previously made backup tapes.

  • If you want an easy media rotation method for preserving multiple full-system backups, tape backup drives are a good choice. In general, tape drives are used where high capacity and high reliability are paramount. They can be expensive initially but are extremely inexpensive when you factor in the low cost of the media over time.

Disadvantages of Tape Backup Drives

Many computer users who once used tape backups for data backup purposes have turned to other technologies for the following reasons:

  • Creating a tape backup copy of files or of a drive requires the use of a special backup program in almost all cases. A few tape drives allow drive letter access to at least part of the tape capacity, but this feature is far from universal, and a special driver program must be used.

  • Retrieving data from most tape backup drives requires that the data files be restored to the hard disk. Other types of backup storage can be treated as a drive letter for direct use from the media.

  • Tape backups store and retrieve data sequentially. The last file backed up can't be accessed until the rest of the tape is read; other types of backup storage use random access, which enables any file on the device to be located and used in mere seconds.

  • Low-cost tape backups usingQIC (Quarter Inch Committee), QIC-Wide, or Travan technology once had little problem keeping up with increases in hard disk capacity and once sold for prices comparable to or less than the hard disks they protected. Today's hard disks have capacities up to 500GB or larger and are far less expensive than most comparably sized tape backups. As a result, more expensive, higher-capacity tape drives are needed to achieve single-cartridge backups. Otherwise, you must load multiple tapes manually or use an autoloader.

  • Newer backup and restore techniques, such as drive imaging/ghosting, rival the ease of use of tape backups and permit data restoration with lower-cost optical storage devices such as rewritable DVD drives. These alternatives are particularly useful if only a few GB of data need to be backed up on a continuing basis.

For these reasons, the once-unassailable position of a tape backup drive as being the must-have data protection accessory is no longer a secure one; plenty of rivals to tape backups are on the market. However, if you can afford a high-quality DDS, DAT 72, or AIT tape drive, you can get a high-performance and high-reliability solution because these same drives are used in the demanding roles of network backup.

legal disclaimer

1) Our website is not responsible for the information contained by this article as well for any and all copyright infringements by authors and writers. E-articles is a free information resource. If you suspect this article for any copyright infringements, please read the Terms of service and contact us to investigate the problem.
2) The E-articles directory team is not responsible for inaccuracies, falsehoods, or any other types of misinformation this tutorial may contain and will not be liable for any loss or damage suffered by a user through the user's reliance on the information gained here. Please read the Terms of service

Useful tools and features

Translate this article to...    Send this article to you or to a friend

Link to this article from your page   
If you like this article (tutorial), please link to it from your web page using the information above. Linking to this page, this is the only way to help us improve our service, the same time providing your visitors with a way to improve their online experience.

related articles

1. Diskette Types and Formats
Before a diskette can be used to store data, you must prepare it by formatting it, although many diskettes nowadays come preformatted. Formatting creates the physical tracks and sectors that the drive uses to store data (called low-level or physical formatting) and the logical structure used by the operating system to organize that data (called logical or DOS formatting). Unlike hard disks, which require two separate formatting passes, FDDs perform both physical and logical formatting in one step. Al...

2. Subcodes
Subcode bytes enable the drive to find songs (which are confusingly also called tracks) along the spiral track and also contain or convey additional information about the disc in general. The subcode bytes are stored as 1 byte per frame, which results in 98 subcode bytes for each sector. Two of these bytes are used as start block and end block markers, leaving 96 bytes of subcode information. These are then divided into eight 12-byte subcode blocks, each of which is assigned a letter designation PW. Each subcode channel can hol...

3. High Capacity Magnetic Storage Devices
High-capacity removable media drives are an ever-shrinking category. With competition at the low end (1GB and under capacities) from USB flash memory keychain drives and at higher capacities from external mini-hard disks (4GB and up), rewritable DVD (8.5GB), and larger USB and FireWire hard disks (20GB and up), there are only two current product families, both from Iomega: Zip. Flexible media, with capacities of 100MB, 250MB, and 750MB REV. Rigid media, with capacity of 35GB (native...

4. Handling CD Read Errors
Handling errors when reading a disc was a big part of the original Red Book CD standard. CDs use parity and interleaving techniques called cross-interleave Reed-Solomon code (CIRC) to minimize the effects of errors on the disk. This works at the frame level. When being stored, the 24 data bytes in each frame are first run through a Reed-Solomon encoder to produce a 4-byte parity code called "Q" parity, which then is added to the 24 data bytes. The resulting 28 bytes are then run though another encoder that uses a different scheme...

5. Floppy Drive Types
As distinct from diskette types and formats, six drive types have been installed in PC-compatible systems: 5.25-inch 160/180 KB (SSDD) Single-Sided, Double-Density(SSDD) was the standard FDD in very early PC-class systems. These drives read and write only SSDD diskettes. 5.25-inch 320/360 KB (DSDD) Double-Sided, Double-Density(DSDD) was the standard FDD in PC-class systems, and was often found as a second FDD in early AT and 386 systems. The...

6. How to choose a Tape Backup Drive
Choosing a tape backup drive can be a simple job if you need to back up a single standalone system with a relatively small hard drive. The decision becomes more complex if the system has a larger hard drive or if you must back up a desktop system as well as a laptop. Choosing a tape backup drive type can be an even more complex program if you must back up a network server's hard drives and perhaps even back up the workstations from the server. As you ponder which backup tape drive you should select, consider the following facto...

7. DVD Copy Protection
DVD video discs employ several levels of protection that are mainly controlled by the DVD Copy Control Association (DVD CCA) and a third-party company called Macrovision. This protection typically applies only to DVD-Video discs, not DVD-ROM software. So, for example, copy protection might affect your ability to make backup copies of The Matrix, but it won't affect a DVD encyclopedia or other software application distributed on DVD-ROM discs. Note that every one of these protection systems has been broken, so with a lit...